El
Espía -
Graham Greene -
Traducción y notas de
Rubén
Moheno
-
Fuente La Jornada
El espionaje hoy es
realmente una rama de la guerra psicológica. El objetivo principal es
sembrar la desconfianza entre los aliados del campo enemigo. Fuchs y Nunn
May pueden haber capacitado a Rusia para avanzar unos pocos años en su
fabricación de bombas atómicas, pero tarde o temprano en cualquier caso los
soviéticos habrían alcanzado paridad suficiente en la habilidad para
destruir al mundo y el intervalo, ya bien corto o largo, no entrañaba ningún
peligro. Occidente, después del shock traumático de Hiroshima, no
estaba preparado para realizar otro ataque atómico unilateral.
El verdadero valor de los dos científicos para los
soviéticos no era el beneficio que recibieron de su información científica
sino el de su captura, y el quiebre en las relaciones anglonorteamericanas
que siguió. Un espía al que se le permite continuar su trabajo sin
interferencias es mucho menos peligroso que el espía atrapado. Cuán atinado
estaba el sis1 al defender a Philby y cuán equivocado el mI52
al forzarlo a descubrirse. Occidente sufrió más por su escapatoria que por
su espionaje.
A veces me gusta imaginar qué habría ocurrido si Kim Philby3
se hubiera convertido realmente, como muchos pronosticaron, en c, el jefe
del Servicio Secreto. La clase de información que habría tenido a su alcance
como c difícilmente habría aumentado mucho en interés, e incluso habría
disminuido: nada que ver con las tripas del asunto, sólo las minutas de
grandes conferencias vacuas de alto nivel. Tarde o temprano ciertamente
habría llegado el momento en que la kgb pensara que era tiempo para arreglar
una filtración al mI5, seguida del escape exitoso de c y la carcajada del
mundo.
Desde que el espionaje se dio a la guerra psicológica, se
dio, también, a la literatura, así que es bueno también examinar
cuidadosamente cualquier memorial de espías. En cualquier caso My Silent
War (Mi Guerra Silenciosa) no es el libro que esperaban los
enemigos de Philby. Su autobiografía es honesta, bien escrita, a menudo
divertida, y la historia que tiene que contar, después de la escapatoria de
Burgess y Maclean, atrapa más que cualquier novela de espionaje que yo pueda
recordar. Se nos dijo que debíamos esperar mucha propaganda, pero no
contiene ninguna, a menos que la digna exposición de sus creencias y motivos
pueda ser llamada propaganda. El fin, por supuesto, se presenta ante sus
ojos para justificar los medios, pero esa es una visión asumida, tal vez
menos abiertamente, por la mayor parte de los hombres involucrados en la
política si hemos de juzgarlos por sus acciones, así el político sea un
Disraeli o un Wilson. "Traicionó a su país"; sí, tal vez lo hizo, ¿pero
quién de nosotros no ha cometido traición contra algo o alguien más
importante que un país? A los ojos de Philby, él trabajaba para dar forma a
las cosas que vendrían, de lo cual se beneficiaría su propio país. En
cualquier caso, los juicios morales están singularmente fuera de lugar en el
espionaje. "Envió hombres a la muerte" es el tipo de frase de archivo que se
ha usado contra Philby o Blake. Así lo hace cualquier comandante militar,
pero la carne de cañón en el espionaje al menos se compone sólo de
voluntarios. Uno no puede llorar razonablemente ante el destino del espía
tránsfuga Volkov, que estaba traicionando a su país por motivos tal vez
menos idealistas que los de Philby.4
Como muchos de los católicos que, en el reinado de
Elizabeth, trabajaron por la victoria de España, Philby tiene una pasmosa
certeza en lo correcto de sus juicios, el fanatismo lógico de un hombre que,
una vez que halló una fe, no va a perderla por las injusticias o las
crueldades inflingidas por la falibilidad de los instrumentos humanos.
Cuánto católico bondadoso debe haber soportado los largos tiempos malos de
la Inquisición con esa fe en el futuro como ancla salvadora. Los errores de
política no habrían tenido ningún efecto sobre su fe, ni el mal cometido por
algunos de sus líderes. Si hubiera habido un Torquemada entonces, en su
corazón él habría sabido que un día habría un Juan XXIII. "No puede
sorprender mucho que yo haya adoptado un punto de vista comunista en los
años treinta; muchos de mis contemporáneos hicieron la misma elección. Pero
muchos de los que hicieron su elección en aquellos días cambiaron de bando
cuando algunos de los peores rasgos del estalinismo se hicieron evidentes.
Yo sostuve el rumbo", escribe Philby, y pregunta con justicia qué
alternativa posible podía haber en la mala era de Baldwin-Chamberlain. "Vi
que el camino me llevaba hacia la posición política del exiliado
quejumbroso, de la variedad Koestler-Crankshaw-Muggeridge, enfrentando al
movimiento que me había decepcionado, al Dios que me había
fallado. Esto parecía un destino horrendo, por más lucrativo que pudiera
haber sido."
Su recuento del servicio secreto británico es
devastadoramente cierto. "La facilidad de mi entrada me sorprendió. Después
se supo que la única investigación que hicieron de mi pasado fue la
referencia de rutina al mI5, que pasó mi nombre a través de sus registros y
regresó con el lacónico señalamiento: ‘Nada registrado en contra.’" (Tuvo
más suerte que yo. Yo tenía un antecedente policíaco porque los papeles de
una demanda por difamación contra mí por la señorita Shirley Temple habían
llegado al director de la fiscalía pública, y por eso la referencia había
sido enviada precisamente a c.) Incluso hubo un momento en el que Philby
dudó que de fuera realmente el servicio secreto donde había entrado. Sus
primeros reportes concretos hicieron que su contacto soviético se inclinara
a pensar que había entrado en la organización equivocada.
Su estudio de personajes es admirable mas no cordial. No me
hablen de escritores fantasmas: sólo Philby pudo haber sido responsable por
esto. Cualquiera que haya sido parte de la sección v estaría de acuerdo en
la apreciación de su jefe. "Cowgill se solazaba en su aislamiento. Era una
de esas almas puras que denunciaba a todos sus oponentes como ‘políticos.’"
El subjefe del servicio secreto se reconoce de inmediato. "Vivian había
dejado muy atrás su mejor momento; si en verdad tuvo alguna vez uno. Con su
figura de carrizo, los rizos de su cabello bien peinados, los ojos húmedos."
Con el propio c, el brigadier Menzies, Philby es inesperadamente amable,
aunque tal vez las estrictas limitaciones de su elogio y una cierta nota de
alta condescendencia no hayan encarecido el retrato del sujeto. Hacia
Skardon, el interrogador del mI5 que quebró a Fuchs, tiene un verdadero
respeto de artesano.5
Si este libro requiriera un subtítulo, yo sugeriría: El
espía como artesano. Nadie pudo tener mejor jefe que Philby cuando
estuvo a cargo de la sección ibérica v. Trabajaba más duro que cualquiera y
no daba nunca la impresión de faena. Siempre estaba relajado, por completo
inalterable. En esos días él estaba, claro está, luchando la misma guerra
que sus colegas: la tensión extrema debió venir después, cuando organizaba
una nueva sección para contender con el espionaje ruso, pero a pesar de que
entonces luchaba una guerra bien distinta, mantuvo su prestigio de artesano.
Estaba decidido a que su nueva sección debía estar mejor organizada que
cualquier otra parte del desvencijado sis. "Cuando nuestro voluminoso
reporte estuvo listo para ser presentado al jefe, sentimos que habíamos
producido el diseño de algo como un servicio, con bastantes alicientes
serios para tentar al hombre joven capaz para verlo como una carrera para
toda la vida." Se dedicó al reclutamiento con cuidado y entusiasmo. "Lo
importante es hacerse de la gente valiosa cuando aún está disponible. Con
las economías de tiempos de paz ya a la vista, sería mucho más fácil
descartar el personal excedente que hallar gente más tarde para llenar los
huecos que pudieran aparecer." Esta vez ningún contacto soviético sería
capaz de preguntarse si había penetrado al equipo correcto. Un orgullo de
artesano, sí, y claro que algo más. Sólo una sección eficiente podría probar
minuciosamente la seguridad del servicio soviético. Era una maniobra
fascinante pese a que sólo una parte sabía que era una guerra falsa.
La historia de cómo, para obtener su posición, eliminó a
Cowgill hace, como admite él, una "lectura amarga, tanto como hace una
escritura amarga"; uno siente por un momento el toque agudo de la espina de
hielo en el corazón. Yo vi el principio de este asunto; de hecho renuncié
antes que aceptar la promoción que era una pieza minúscula en la maquinaria
de su intriga.6 Entonces lo atribuí a una ambición personal de
poder, la única característica en Philby que pensé que era desagradable.
Ahora me alegra haber estado equivocado. Estaba sirviendo a una causa y no a
sí mismo, y así vuelve mi viejo gusto por él, cuando recuerdo con placer
aquellos largos almuerzos de domingo en St. Albans en los que toda la
subsección se relajaba bajo su liderazgo durante unas pocas horas de bebida
abundante, y más tarde los encuentros con una pinta en las noches de guardia
contra incendio en el pub atrás de St. James Street. Si uno cometía un error
de juicio es seguro que él lo minimizaría y lo cubriría, sin crítica, con su
vacilante ingenio tartamudo. Tenía todas las pequeñas lealtades hacia sus
colegas, y claro que su gran lealtad era desconocida para nosotros. No me
parece la menos admirable entre las cualidades humanas de Philby que durante
todos esos años peligrosos hospedó a Burgess, sin que le fallaran los
nervios o el humor, o su afecto.
Unos años más tarde, después de su exoneración por Macmillan
en la Cámara de los Comunes, yo y otro amigo de Kim estábamos en Crowborough
y pensamos buscarlo. El pasto crecido no mostraba ningún signo de atención y
no hubo ninguna respuesta a la campana cuando la sonamos. Miramos a través
de las ventanas de una fea y gran casa eduardiana, en los límites del bosque
Ashdown, en este Surrey de los pobres. La correspondencia no se había
recogido en mucho tiempo; el piso bajo la puerta estaba inundado de folletos
publicitarios. En la cocina había algunas botellas de leche vacías y una
solitaria taza sucia y un plato en el fregadero. Era más como un campamento
gitano abandonado que la morada de un hombre con esposa e hijos. No lo
sabíamos, pero ya había partido hacia Beirut; la última etapa de su viaje
hacia Moscú, el hogar que nunca había visto. Es seguro que después de
treinta años encubierto se ha ganado el derecho a descansar.
Notas
1 sis (también llamado mI6)
es el departamento de servicio secreto, con actividad fuera de Gran
Bretaña y a cargo de todo el trabajo de inteligencia, tanto el de
espionaje como el de contraespionaje.
2 mI5, policía y servicios
de seguridad dentro del territorio inglés, incluidas las áreas
ultramarinas.
3 Kim Philby, hijo del
establishment inglés, trabajó durante treinta años como agente
encubierto y llegó a ser jefe de contrainteligencia soviética en el sis.
Así, el hombre que realizaba operaciones contra los soviéticos estaba
trabajando realmente para ellos. Fue el enlace del sis con la cia y el
fbi en Washington, donde su memoria causa agudo escozor hasta la fecha.
En 1963 su situación se hizo insostenible y debió escapar hacia la urss.
Allá fue nombrado coronel de la kgb, recibió la Orden de la Bandera Roja
y la Orden de Lenin. Graham Greene siguió siendo su amigo, lo visitó en
Moscú cuatro veces, y para el asombro del mundo literario y el
establishment inglés, hizo este escrito como prólogo a su autobiografía.
Philby fue enterrado con honores en el Kremlin cuatro meses antes de la
caída del bloque soviético.
4 En 1945 un hombre con
acento ruso penetró en la embajada británica en Estambul y pidió hablar
con un diplomático de alto rango. Dijo llamarse Konstantin Volkov,
pertenecer a la nkdvd (luego kgb) y tener una propuesta a cambio de un
salvoconducto a Chipre y una cifra exacta, 27 mil 500 libras esterlinas.
Ofrecía un gran bagaje de información sobre los soviéticos; entre otras
cosas, nombres de agentes que trabajaban para los rusos en el gobierno
de Londres, dos de ellos en el Foreign Office y un funcionario de
contrainteligencia, presumiblemente Philby. El diplomático que lo
entrevistaba se comunicó a Londres y, después de una considerable demora
(veintiún días), llegó a Estambul el propio Kim Philby (quien más tarde
señaló que ese fue un momento verdaderamente difícil). A Volkov no se le
vio más. En el típico estilo soviético, un avión ruso fuera de programa
aterrizó en Estambul, un auto se le aproximó antes de que la torre de
control reaccionara y unos hombres subieron un bulto vendado a bordo y
el avión despegó. El bulto vendado era, muy probablemente, el
infortunado Volkov.
5 Es sabido que la
información confiable se obtiene mejor cuando se interroga a un
sospechoso con base en una masa de información que la organización de
inteligencia ya posee previamente. William Skardon describió así el
momento decisivo: "Él [Klaus Fuchs] estaba obviamente sometido a una
presión mental considerable. Yo sugerí que debía despejar su mente y
aclarar su conciencia contándome la historia completa. Él dijo: ‘Usted
nunca me convencerá para que hable.’ En ese punto nos fuimos a almorzar.
Durante la comida pareció muy abstraído y estar resolviendo la cuestión
[…] Sugirió que volviéramos de inmediato a su casa. Al llegar dijo haber
decidido que sería de su mayor interés contestar mis preguntas. Entonces
le hice ciertas preguntas y en respuesta me dijo que estaba comprometido
con el espionaje desde mediados de 1942 hasta hacia un año
aproximadamente. Dijo que había un flujo continuo de información
relativa a la energía atómica, mediante encuentros irregulares pero
frecuentes." (Reporte de W. Skardon, agente de la contrainteligencia
inglesa mI5, enero 31, 1950). El interrogador no sólo se ganó la
confianza del científico nuclear para que confesara su parte, sino
además para que identificara por fotografías a su contacto en Estados
Unidos, Harry Gold. Gold, quien también estaba con ánimo platicador,
permitió seguir la cadena que llevaba inexorablemente a Julius y
(supuestamente) a Ethel Rosenberg. Ambos fueron ejecutados en la silla
eléctrica. El presidente Eisenhower no perdonó la vida a esa mujer, con
la divisa de que entonces los soviéticos emplearían más mujeres para su
espionaje.
6 Cuando Greene renunció la guerra estaba
prácticamente ganada. El escritor dijo muchas veces que estaba aburrido
del trabajo de oficina y deseaba volver a ser escritor de tiempo
completo.
Biography
- Fuente
Wikipedia
Harold Adrian Russell "Kim" Philby or H.A.R.
Philby (OBE: 1946-1965), (1 January, 1912 – 11 May, 1988) was a high-ranking
member of British intelligence, a communist, and spy for the Soviet
Union's NKVD and KGB.
In 1963, Philby was revealed as a member of the spy ring
known as the Cambridge Five, along with Donald Maclean, Guy Burgess, Anthony
Blunt and John Cairncross. Of the five, Philby is believed to have done the
most damage to British and American intelligence, providing classified
information to the Soviet Union that caused the deaths of scores of agents.
Early life
Born in Ambala Haryana, India, Philby was the son of St.
John Philby, the British Army officer, diplomat, explorer, author, and
Orientalist who converted to
Islam and was advisor to King Ibn Sa'ud of
Saudi
Arabia. He was nicknamed after the protagonist in
Rudyard Kipling's novel
Kim about a young Irish Indian boy who spies for the British in India
during the 19th century. After leaving Westminster School in 1928 at the age
of 16 Philby studied history and economics at Trinity College, Cambridge
where he was introduced to and became an admirer of Communism. It has been
suggested that his father, while not a spy himself, was opposed to the
British establishment and was thus Kim Philby's inspiration and probable
mentor. The elder Philby died in 1960.
Philby asked one of his tutors Maurice Dobb how he could
serve the Communist movement. Dobb referred him to a Communist front
organization which in turn passed Philby to the Comintern underground in
Vienna Austria. The front organisation was the World Federation for the
Relief of the Victims of German Fascism in Paris, France. The World
Federation was one of innumerable fronts operated by the German Communist
Willi Münzenberg who was a leading Soviet agent in the West.
Espionage activities
The Soviet intelligence service itself (then the OGPU)
recruited Philby on the strength of his work for the Comintern. His case
officers included Arnold Deutsch [OTTO],
Theodore Maly [MAN], and Alexander Orlov [SWEDE].
Each of them suffered under Stalin's purges.
In 1933, Kim Philby went to Vienna to aid refugees who were
fleeing Nazi Germany. There he met Litzi Friedman, a Jewish Communist whom
he married and brought to Britain to save her life. (The alliance did not
outlast the Spanish Civil War.) In 1936, as ordered by Moscow, Philby began
cultivating a pro-fascist persona, appearing at Anglo-German meetings and
editing a pro-Hitler magazine. In 1937, he went to Spain to cover the Civil
War, first, as a freelance journalist, and then as correspondent for The
Times — reporting the war from Francisco Franco's perspective. Among his
espionage duties for the Soviets was the writing of spurious love letters (interlaced
with codewords), addressed to a girl in Paris who lived on the Rue de
Grenelle. Only years later did he discover to his fury that the letters were
actually addressed to the Soviet Embassy and that the possibility existed he
could have been so easily found out. In December 1937, near the Spanish town
Teruel, a shell hit the car in which he was traveling, killing three fellow
journalists, but only wounding Philby, whom Franco decorated for bravery.
In 1940, Guy Burgess, who was working in Section D of SIS (later
MI6) introduced him to Marjorie Maxse, an SIS officer, and Philby was
recruited as a British intelligence officer. When Section D itself was
destroyed (and Burgess booted out), Philby, who had been an instructor in
the arts of "black propaganda", was retained and appointed as head of
Section V, the Iberian Section, in charge of Spain, Portugal, Gibraltar, and
Africa. As head of counter-espionage, Philby performed his duties so
successfully, according to Seale and McConville, that he not only
neutralized the Abwehr's attempts to sabotage British shipping, but he also
came to the attention of "C", Sir Stewart Menzies, who in 1944 appointed him
to the key position as head of the new Section IX: counter-espionage against
the Soviet Union. As a Soviet agent, Philby had accomplished something of a
coup.
All went well for Philby until August, 1945, when
Constantine Volkov, an officer of the NKVD (later KGB) decided to defect to
Britain with the promise that he would reveal the names of Soviet agents in
SIS and the Foreign Office. When the report reached Philby's desk, with a
bit of luck and clever scheming, he managed to get the assignment. He thus
flew to Istanbul by way of Cairo. What with the plane being delayed by
storms, the ambassador being on his yacht in the Bosporus, the Russians had
time to whisk Volkov off to Moscow and Philby returned to London after a
close call.
After the war, Philby was sent as Head of Station to
Istanbul under the cover of First Secretary to the British Embassy. While
there, he received a visit from Guy Burgess. In 1949, Philby's next — and
last — assignment was as First Secretary to the British Embassy in
Washington, where he acted as liaison between the British Embassy and the
newly formed CIA. His luck ran out, however. First came the discovery of the
cryptonym HOMER (Donald Maclean) in the VENONA decrypts — a "jigsaw puzzle"
of decrypts, decoded piecemeal because some Soviet code clerk had used a one-time
pad twice; then came another visit from Guy Burgess who ensconced himself in
the Philby household for a year and proceeded to behave very badly. Burgess
was declared persona non grata, as was Philby soon after.
After the defection of Burgess and Maclean, Philby was asked
to resign from SIS, and he spent the next several years being questioned by
MI5 and SIS. Since he did not break, however, he was finally cleared of
being the "Third Man" by the Foreign Secretary Harold Macmillan in the House
of Commons. Eventually he was re-employed as an SIS agent, with the cover as
a correspondent in Beirut for The Observer and The Economist.
Always in danger of having his cover blown by the next
Soviet defector, Philby, confronted by new evidence brought to him by an old
SIS friend, Nicholas Elliott, finally defected to the Soviet Union in
January 1963, departing Beirut on the Soviet freighter Dolmatova.
Postwar career
After these two disasters, the CIA and MI6 largely gave up
their attempts to plant agents in Soviet territory. Philby was also able to
tell Moscow just how much the CIA knew about its operations. Moscow asked
Philby not to bother saving spies who had served their purpose, but he sat
on several reports that revealed the names of other Soviet spies anyway.
In January 1949, the British Government was informed that
Venona project intercepts showed that nuclear secrets were passed to the
Soviet Union from the British Embassy in Washington in 1944 and 1945 by an
agent code-named 'Homer'. In 1950, Philby was asked to help track down this
agent. Knowing from the start that 'Homer' was his old university friend,
Second Secretary Donald MacLean, Philby warned MacLean in 1951, leading to
his two friends' defection (and ultimately to his downfall).
Washington, D.C.
In October 1949 Philby arrived in Washington as British
intelligence liaison to the newly created U.S. intelligence agencies under
the National Security Act of 1947. Philby received Venona material which the
U.S. was sharing with the UK, but he did not have information about the
source, since Venona was one of the most highly rated top secrets. He shared
a house in Washington, at 4100 Nebraska Avenue, N.W, with his friend from
the Cambridge days, fellow British diplomat, intelligence officer and Soviet
penetration agent, Guy Burgess.
In 1949, Philby was in Washington, D.C., as the MI6 liaison
to the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). The two agencies launched an
attempted revolution in Soviet-influenced Albania. The exiled King Zog had
offered his troops and other volunteers to help, but, for three years, every
attempted landing in Albania met with a Soviet or Albanian Communist ambush
(the Soviets knew the emergency radio call routine). Philby's betrayal cost
300 Albanian lives, and a similar betrayal occurred in the Ukraine. Couriers
would travel to Soviet territory and disappear, and no useful information
was coming out.
Philby is believed to have passed to Moscow information on
the United States' small stockpile of atomic weapons and its capacity (at
that time, severely limited) to produce new atomic bombs. Based in part on
that information, Stalin went ahead with a 1948 blockade of West Berlin and
began a large-scale offensive armament of Kim Il Sung's North Korean Army
and Air Force that would later culminate in the Korean War. The latter
conflict would later consume the lives of over one million Koreans, and
about 30,000 U.S./Allied soldiers and marines.
When MacLean was identified in April 1951, surveillance
commenced to obtain evidence independent of Venona, as the U.S. and UK did
not want to reveal the existence of Venona. MacLean defected to Moscow with
Guy Burgess a month later in May 1951. Philby came under instant suspicion
as the third man who had tipped them off.
That year, Philby resigned under a cloud, and was denied his
pension until an internal investigation failed to come up with definitive
proof of his treachery. On October 25, 1955, against all expectations, he
was 'cleared' by Foreign Secretary Harold Macmillan in an ill-timed
statement made in the House of Commons: "While in government service he
carried out his duties ably and conscientiously, and I have no reason to
conclude that Mr. Philby has at any time betrayed the interests of his
country, or to identify him with the so-called 'Third Man,' if indeed there
was one."
Beirut
Thus, in 1956 Philby was again in the employ of MI6 as an "informant
on retainer" and was supposedly involved in Operation Musketeer, the British,
French, and Israeli plan to attack Egypt and depose Gamal Abdel Nasser.
Better attested is his role as Middle East correspondent for
the British newspaper The Economist, which also led to his exposure.
Sometime in late 1962, a British-Jewish woman, Flora Solomon, was attending
a cocktail party in Tel Aviv and made a comment about how Philby, the
journalist in Beirut, displayed sympathy for Arabs in his articles. She said
that his masters were the Soviets and that she knew that he had always
worked for them. The comment was overheard by someone at the party and was
relayed to the offices of MI5 in London, which sent Victor Rothschild to
interview her. Mrs. Solomon declared that she would never testify against
Philby, but she admitted that he had told her he was a spy and had tried to
recruit her to the Communist cause.
Although MI5 and MI6 could not immediately agree on how to
deal with Philby, it was eventually agreed that a personal friend of Philby
from his MI6 days, Nicolas Elliott, would be sent to confront him in Beirut.
There seemed to be a constant leak of information and it is alleged that
there was a high-level mole in MI5 those days. Although it is unclear
whether Philby was aware of the developments against him vis-a-vis Flora
Solomon or whether he knew about the defection of Anatoly Golitsyn (which
led to the arrest, escape, and defection to Moscow of fellow MI6 officer and
Soviet agent George Blake), there is evidence that in the last few months of
1962 Philby began to drink heavily and his behaviour became increasingly
erratic. Philby may have also been warned by Yuri Modin, a top Soviet
handler who had served in the Soviet embassy in London, when he travelled to
Beirut in December 1962. Modin was the controller of the "Cambridge Five".
It is reported that the first thing that Philby said upon
meeting with Elliott was that he was "half expecting" to see him. Many
sources claim that he confessed immediately when confronted with the
evidence, while others, including Philby himself, have maintained that he
continued to downplay the accusations. Although a further interrogation was
scheduled in the last week of January 1963, Philby disappeared on January
23. Records later revealed that the Dolmatova, a Soviet freighter was
called to port in Beirut on this date and had left so quickly its cargo
remained scattered on the dock.
Moscow
Kim Philby surfaced in Moscow, and quickly discovered that
he was not a colonel in the KGB, but still just agent TOM. It was 10 years
before he walked through the doors of KGB headquarters. He suffered severe
bouts of alcoholism. In Moscow, he seduced MacLean's American wife, Melinda,
and abandoned his own wife, Eleanor, who left Russia in 1965.
According to information contained in the Mitrokhin Archive,
the head of KGB counterintelligence, Oleg Kalugin met Philby in 1972 and
found him to be 'a wreck of a man'; "The bent figure caromed off the walls
as he walked. Reeking of vodka, he mumbled something unintelligible in
atrocious, slurred Russian."
Over the next few years Kalugin and the Young Turks in the
Foreign Intelligence Directorate rehabilitated Philby, using him to devise
active measures, and to run seminars for young agents about to be sent to
Great Britain, Australia, or Ireland. In 1972 he married a Russian woman,
Rufina Pukhova, who was twenty years his junior, with whom he lived until
his death at age 76, in 1988. His autobiography "My Silent War" was
published in the West in 1968. Only posthumously did he receive the praise
and appreciation which had escaped him in life; he was awarded a hero's
funeral and numerous posthumous medals by a grateful USSR.
Philby was a close friend of the novelist Graham Greene, who
reportedly left MI6 rather than become involved in exposing Philby. Greene's
biographer, Norman Sherry, had this to say:
-
-
’Perhaps Greene, always intuitive, resigned because
he suspected that Philby was a Russian penetration agent. … If
Greene did suspect Philby, it would be just the kind of thing that
would catapult him out of the service rather than share his
suspicions with the authorities.
-
1912 Birth in India
-
1919 Attended Aldro preparatory school in Eastbourne
-
1924 Was a King's Scholar at Westminster School
-
1929 Entered Trinity College, Cambridge at the age of 17
to read history.
-
1930 Guy Burgess arrived at Trinity from Eton.
-
1931 Joined the Cambridge
University Socialist Society. Labour government of Ramsay
MacDonald defeated 27th October. Philby became a more ardent socialist.
After obtaining only a third in his history exams he transferred to
economics.
-
1932 Became treasurer of the Cambridge University
Socialist Society.
-
1933 Left Cambridge a convinced Communist with a degree
in economics, then went to Vienna where Chancellor Dr Engelbert Dollfuss
was preparing the first 'putsch' in February 1934. Philby became a
Soviet agent.
-
1934 Clash between the Austrian government and
socialists in Vienna. On 24 February Philby married Alice (Litzy)
Friedmann, born Kohlmann; then in May, after the collapse of the
socialist movement in Vienna, he returned with his wife to England. He
began work as a sub-editor of a Liberal monthly review, and joined Guy
Burgess as a member of the Anglo-German Fellowship. (Philby edited the
fellowship's pro-Hitler magazine, supported by Nazi funds). To cover up
his communist background he also made repeated visits to Berlin for
talks with the German Propaganda Ministry and with von Ribbentrop's
Foreign Office.
-
1937 In February Philby arrived in Spain to report on
the Spanish Civil War from Franco's side. 20 May, 1937 he became
correspondent of The Times with Franco's forces.
-
1938 Awarded the 'Red Cross of Military Merit' by Franco
personally.
-
1939 In July, left Spain and became war correspondent of
The Times at the British Headquarters in Arras.
-
1940 In June, after the evacuation of British Forces
from the European mainland, he returned to Britain. Recruited by the
British Secret Service and attached to the Secret Intelligence Service
under Guy Burgess in Section D. Assigned to school for under-cover work,
but later transferred to the teaching staff of a new school for general
training in techniques of sabotage and subversion at Beaulieu, Hampshire.
-
1941 Transferred to MI6, Section V (Five). Philby took
charge of the Iberian sub-section, responsible for British Intelligence
in Spain and Portugal. Trained James Jesus Angleton in the arts and
crafts of counterespionage.
-
1942 Married his second wife Aileen Furse. Office of
Strategic Services group under Norman Pearson arrived in London for
liaison with British Secret Service. Philby's area of responsibility
grew to include North African and Italian espionage under newly formed
counter-intelligence units.
-
1943 Section V moved from St Albans to London, bringing
Philby closer to the centres of power.
-
1944 Appointed head of Section IX, newly created to
operate against communism and the Soviet Union.
-
1945 In September Soviet intelligence officer
Konstantin Volkov based at the Soviet
embassy in Ankara seriously threatened Philby's position by offering to
defect and provide the names of two agents working in the Foreign Office
and one in MI6 (probably Philby). The offer was sent to Philby as head
of the Section IX, Soviet counterintelligence. Soon afterwards, Volkov
was kidnapped by Soviet agents and taken to the Lubyanka in Moscow for
interrogation and execution.
-
1946 Took a field appointment - officially as First
Secretary with the British embassy in Turkey, actually as head of the
Turkish MI6 station.
-
1949 Became MI6 representative in Washington, as senior
British Secret Service officer working in liaison with the Federal
Bureau of Investigation and the newly created CIA. He occasionally
visited Arlington Hall for discussions about VENONA; furthermore, he
regularly received copies of summaries of VENONA translations as part of
his official duties. He sat in on a Special Policy Committee directing
the ill-fated Anglo-US attempt to infiltrate anti-communist agents into
Albania to topple the Enver Hoxha régime.
-
1950 Guy Burgess arrived in Washington on assignment as
Second Secretary of the British Embassy, and Philby invited him to stay
at his house.
-
1951 Philby learnt of the tightening net of suspicion
surrounding Foreign Office diplomat and Soviet agent Donald Maclean,
whose British embassy position at the end of the war had placed him on
the Combined Policy Committee on Atomic Energy as its British joint
secretary. Burgess's alcoholism caused Ambassador Franks to remove him
and he returned to England. On 25 May, Burgess and Maclean disappeared
from Britain, with help from Philby, having escaped via the Baltic to
the Soviet Union. Philby summoned to London for interrogation and asked
to resign from the Foreign Service.
-
1952 In the summer a secret trial took place in which
Philby underwent questioning about his activities.
-
1955 The British Government published a 'White Paper' (report)
on the Burgess-Maclean affair. On October 25, questions tabled in
parliament asking about the 'third man', Philby. Harold Macmillan,
foreign secretary in the Eden cabinet, stated that no evidence existed
of Philby having betrayed the interests of Britain. Nevertheless, the
Foreign Service dismissed him because of his association with Burgess.
-
1956 In September British secret service arranged Philby
to work for The Observer in Beirut as correspondent of and also
The Economist; But that year Dick White, who suspected Philby of
working as a Soviet agent, became head of MI6.
-
1957 Aileen, Philby's second wife, died.
-
1958 Married Eleanor Brewer.
-
1962 George Blake unmasked. Philby then confirmed as an
identified Soviet agent.
-
1963 23 January, Philby disappeared in Beirut. The
Soviet Union announced that it has granted Philby political asylum in
Moscow. On 3 March, Mrs. Philby received a telegram from Philby
postmarked Cairo, Egypt. On 3 June Izvestia located Philby with
the Imam of Yemen. On 1 July, the British Government admitted that
Philby had worked as a Soviet agent before 1946 and identified him as
the 'third man'.
-
1965 Awarded the Order of the Red Banner, one of the
highest honours of the Soviet Union.
-
1971, marries Rufina Ivanovna in Moscow.
-
1988 Death at the age 76.
Kim
Philby Was Here -
Carlson, Amb. Richard, Carlson, Buckley
- Source FDD
-
The
Open Republic Institute - January 03, 2006
The downtown of this
lovely port city now looks much as it did in the days when the Soviet spy
and British Secret Intelligence officer Kim Philby lived and worked here.
Beirut has morphed from the post civil war ruins of the
‘80's and ‘90's — crumbled mansions and blown-out hotels, dead dogs on the
sidewalks — to a recreation of Ottoman-style buildings of polished granite,
sandstone and marble. Memories of Philby linger like brazier smoke.
Harold Adrian Russell Philby — nicknamed Kim by his father
from the title of the Rudyard Kipling book — was one of the most successful
penetration agents ever to work against the West for Stalin and the KGB. In
the early 1930s, Philby secretly joined the Soviet intelligence service and
then became a reporter for The Times of London for which he covered the
Spanish Civil War. Within a few years he was recruited from his scribe's day
job into Britain's MI 6 and quickly (and ironically) rose to head their
Soviet counter-intelligence directorate. Later, reporting to the KGB, he
moved to Washington as the British liaison to the FBI and CIA. He even dined
at J. Edgar Hoover's home in Northwest Washington. His active covert service
for Soviet intelligence — 1934 to 1963 — was during some of that agencies'
most murderous years.
Philby arrived in Beirut in the summer of 1956, a few weeks
before the Suez crisis exploded. He had been fired from MI6 in 1951, under
suspicion as the “third man” who had warned the British traitors Guy Burgess
and Donald MacLean that MI 5 had them under surveillance as Soviet spies.
Shortly before they were to be arrested they fled to Moscow.
In Beirut, Philby was under waning suspicion by the British
of being a Soviet agent. Philby was very pro-Arab and equally anti-Israel
and had arrived in Beirut as a correspondent for the Economist and the
Guardian of London, though he maintained his connections with British
intelligence and was given intelligence assignments by MI 6.
For his first months in Beirut, Philby lived with his father,
St. John Philby, then a famed Arabist and explorer. St. John had converted
to radical Islam — he had become a Wahabbi and called himself Hajj Abdullah
— and at 71 was living with his young Saudi mistress “Rosie” and their two
sons Khalid and Faris in a white stone villa in the mountain village of
Altajun, twenty minutes west of Beirut.
St. John (pronounced by the British as “Sin-Jin”) had gone
to the Arabian desert after WW1 and had explored it by camel. He befriended
a desert warrior named Ibn Saud, who later seized all the arid land from the
Red Sea to the Persian Gulf, made himself king and named the new country
Saudi Arabia, after his family. St. John Philby renounced England and helped
King Saud create friendly relations with the US government and a consortium
of American oil companies.
St. John's mistress was one of two teenage sisters, both
slaves from Balucchistan, who King Saud had given him as a gift in 1948.
(Philby kept one and sent the other back, as the pair bickered, he
complained.) St. John's wife of forty years, Kim's mother Dora, remained in
an alcoholic haze back in England, and she ultimately died from drinking.
St. John's small villa was called “Mahalla Jamil” (beautiful
place) and was crowded with servants and Kim's half-brothers, about five and
six old, and the plump stepmother Rosie, who wore the same bathrobe and
slippers all day, knew no English and whose hobby, or so Kim complained to
friends, was painting her toenails and wolfing down candy by the sack full.
By the fall of 1956, Kim had moved downtown to his own
quarters and taken up with Eleanor Brewer, the wife of his old friend, the
New York Time's Beirut correspondent Sam Pope Brewer. They had met at the
bar of the St. George's Hotel.
Eleanor Brewer was from Seattle, Washington and had a young
daughter with Brewer, who was covering Nasser in Egypt and traveling a great
deal in the region. By the time Brewer discovered he had been cuckolded
Philby's wife had died in England from general craziness fueled by alcohol,
like his mother. Philby confronted Brewer, who was suspicious, and announced
the affair. He told Brewer Eleanor wanted a divorce and that they planned to
marry. Brewer's response, according to accounts Philby gave to friends, may
contain a clue as to Brewer's emotional commitment to Eleanor. He said to
Philby, “Well, that sounds like the best solution. What do you make of the
situation in Iraq?”
Kim and Eleanor and Kim's pet fox “Jackie”, who he had
raised from a cub (and had trained to use a toilet, and to drink Scotch
whiskey, as he himself did every morning) moved to a fifth floor flat about
500 yards from Kim's “office” at the bar of the Normandie Hotel where he
daily chatted-up journalist friends and intelligence officers, read the
French and British papers, drank uncountable liters of whiskey and gin, and
presumably worried about being caught for the serious deceptions in which he
had engaged for more than two decades.
Fears of being exposed were legitimate. In January of 1963,
Philby learned that he himself was again under strong suspicion by MI 6 of
working for the Soviets.(He had been privately accused of treachery some
years before in London but had successfully denied the allegations.) Soon,
Philby was confronted in Beirut by an old British intelligence colleague,
the MI6 officer Nick Elliot, who had specifically flown in to accuse Philby
of treason. Philby gave Elliot a written confession of a sort, promised to
discuss it further over the next few days, and then fled to the USSR;
probably aboard the Russian freighter Dolmatova which left the Beirut port
so quickly its cargo remained scattered on the dock. (Although others have
said that Philby, aided by the KGB, was whisked to Syria in a truck and then
taken on foot through Armenia into the Soviet Union, that the Dolmatova's
quick departure was a ruse.)
Kim was later joined in Moscow by Eleanor Brewer but, true
to his life's pattern, he abandoned her for Melinda MacLean, the American
wife of his fellow British spy Donald McLean, who himself had defected to
Moscow in 12 years before. (Philby later also abandoned Melinda. To
paraphrase the writer Phillip Knightley, who spent much time with Philby, he
loved deceit, all those lonely years.)
The Normandie Hotel on Avenue des Francaise is long gone,
bulldozed into landfill. So is Kim and Eleanor's apartment building on the
Rue Kantari. Jackie the fox was killed in a fall from the building's roof in
1962. There was speculation that Jackie was drunk. Philby, who betrayed his
country and his friends and his lovers had deep feelings for his pet.
Eleanor told friends that he mourned its death for weeks.
The St. George Hotel where Philby first met Eleanor Brewer
is an empty shell, its façade heavily damaged in the explosion which wiped
former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri and 19 others from the Beirut
waterfront last February.
Eleanor returned to the US from Moscow and died in Seattle
in 1968. Our friend Nigel West, the British author and expert on espionage,
told us at lunch in London recently that Melinda MacLean, who had left her
husband for Philby and had then been dropped by him for a young Russian
woman named Rufina, is still alive. Melinda is very old and lives in
seclusion in New York City. Rufina Philby, now his widow, and well debriefed
by various intelligence agencies, is seen occasionally in and out of London.
She has written a surprisingly good book about her life with her husband
with some help from a Western intelligence officer friend.
Nick Elliot, the British intelligence officer who confronted
Philby in Beirut died a few years ago. Elliot had privately denied the rumor
that MI 6 used him to stampede Philby into defecting to avoid the scandal of
a public trial, although there is no question that the British government,
which had had its Profumo/Christine Keeler scandal, very much wished to
avoid further bad publicity. Elliot said privately that Philby did sign a
confession shortly before he defected and that Elliot had been authorized by
the British Attorney General to grant Philby immunity in return for a full
confession — but much of what he said turned out to be heavy with lies,
particularly the names of fellow MI 5 and MI 6 officers who he falsely
claimed were part of his Soviet spy network.)
St. John Philby, who had previously fallen out with King
Saud, mended that fence in 1957 and returned to Saudi Arabia with Rosie and
their boys Khalid and Faris. St. John died the next year; Rosie, if she were
alive, would be about 70. She and the boys have disappeared into history's
dustbin.
But St. John's old mountain villa remains. We drove to the
village on Mount Lebanon looking for it. Ajaltun is now a mid-sized town,
with much new construction. We found the mayor and a half dozen of his
cronies lounging in the sunny town square. Only one of the men had ever
heard the name Philby, “The spy” not the father, and one knew of a house
named Mahalla Jamil. But there is a street with that name “beautiful place”
— the mayor said and sketched a map. We canvassed houses along the narrow
road that looks out over Beirut.
“I remember them,” said Salim Ghnem, a cheery and dignified
65 year-old engineer. “I used to live nearby. The old man, with the beard,
was not popular with the neighbors.” Mr. Ghnem piled into our car to show us
the house about a half-mile away.
Mahalla Jamil, a two-story hillside house of white stone, is
larger than it was when St John and Rosie and Kim and the hired help and the
small boys Khalid and Faris were there. A new addition has been added, said
Mr. Ghnem, who didn't know the current owners, who weren't at home. He
doubted they knew anything about the house's past. He walked nearby and
fetched Nicholas Mrad, an electrician who was home for lunch and who has
lived two houses away up the hill since he was born in 1951.
Mr. Mrad said he remembered the Philby family: the father
was an old fellow with a white beard; the neighbors, mostly Christian didn't
like the man and sometimes threw rocks at the house because the old man was
a Muslim and frequently “spanked” his young wife; the oldest son was a
middle-aged man who visited frequently and sometimes spent the night. Mr.
Mrad said he was then about the age of the two young boys and was very
friendly with them, one of them in particular.
Mr. Mrad trotted up the hill to his house. He returned with
a black and white photo. He pointed to himself, age six, wearing a cowboy
suit, posed with two women and two other boys wearing costumes. He
identified “the mother.” “Everyone called her ‘Rosie”,” he said, and the
other woman was the “family cook.” And the two boys in sailor suits? He
couldn't remember the name of one of them. “But this was my friend,” he said
and placed his finger on the boy's chest. “His name was Khalid,” he said.
Philby died in
Moscow in 1988 and was buried there, less than four years before the USSR,
to which he had devoted his entire adult life, ceased to exist.